
The phrase who says but what about second breakfast is a playful nod to the beloved character of Hobbits from J.R.R. Tolkien's *The Lord of the Rings*, who are famously known for their love of food and multiple daily meals. This whimsical question highlights the Hobbit tradition of enjoying not just breakfast, but also second breakfast, elevenses, luncheon, afternoon tea, dinner, and supper. It has since become a cultural reference, often used humorously to express a love for food or to emphasize the importance of taking time to enjoy life’s simple pleasures. Whether in fandom discussions or everyday conversations, the idea of a second breakfast resonates as a charming reminder of the joy found in indulging in an extra meal.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Origin | The phrase "What about second breakfast?" is famously spoken by the character Merry Brandybuck in The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001 film). |
| Speaker | Merry Brandybuck (played by Dominic Monaghan) |
| Context | The line is delivered during a scene where the Fellowship is discussing meal times while traveling. |
| Full Quote | "Don’t you know what today is? It’s the first day of the rest of our lives! But what about second breakfast?" |
| Cultural Impact | The phrase has become a popular meme and reference among Lord of the Rings fans, often used humorously to emphasize the importance of multiple meals. |
| Hobbit Meal Times | Hobbits are known for their love of food and traditionally have seven meals a day: breakfast, second breakfast, elevenses, luncheon, afternoon tea, dinner, and supper. |
| Meme Usage | Commonly used to jokingly advocate for additional snacks or meals throughout the day. |
| Merchandise | The quote appears on various Lord of the Rings-themed merchandise, including mugs, t-shirts, and posters. |
| Fan Community | Widely celebrated in fan discussions, art, and cosplay, often highlighting the whimsical nature of Hobbit culture. |
| Relevance Today | The phrase resonates with modern audiences who appreciate the idea of indulging in extra meals or snacks. |
Explore related products
What You'll Learn
- Hobbit Meal Traditions: Exploring the cultural significance of multiple daily meals in Hobbiton
- Second Breakfast Foods: Popular dishes Hobbits enjoy during their mid-morning feast
- Social Aspects: How second breakfast fosters community and bonding among Hobbits
- Historical Origins: Tracing the roots of second breakfast in Middle-earth lore
- Modern Adaptations: How fans incorporate second breakfast into their daily routines today

Hobbit Meal Traditions: Exploring the cultural significance of multiple daily meals in Hobbiton
The phrase "What about second breakfast?" has become iconic among fans of J.R.R. Tolkien's *The Hobbit* and *The Lord of the Rings*, immortalized by the character Merry in *The Fellowship of the Ring*. This line humorously highlights a central aspect of Hobbit culture: their love for frequent, hearty meals. In Hobbiton, the daily rhythm is structured around multiple meals, each serving not just as a source of sustenance but as a cornerstone of social and cultural life. Hobbits traditionally enjoy seven meals a day: breakfast, second breakfast, elevenses, luncheon, afternoon tea, dinner, and supper. This tradition reflects their agrarian lifestyle, where food is abundant and communal dining fosters a sense of unity and contentment.
The concept of "second breakfast" is more than just a quirky habit; it embodies the Hobbit philosophy of savoring life's simple pleasures. Unlike other Middle-earth cultures, Hobbits prioritize comfort and joy over grandeur or ambition. Their meals are not merely functional but are rituals that celebrate the bounty of the Shire. Second breakfast, in particular, is a time to pause and indulge after the morning's activities, reinforcing the idea that life should be enjoyed at a leisurely pace. This practice also aligns with their agricultural roots, as farmers and laborers require frequent nourishment to sustain their energy throughout the day.
The cultural significance of these multiple meals extends beyond physical sustenance. Hobbit meal traditions are deeply tied to their sense of community and hospitality. Sharing food is a way of strengthening bonds and welcoming others into their homes. For instance, Bilbo Baggins' famous elevenses in *The Hobbit* is a grand affair, showcasing his generosity and the importance of hospitality in Hobbit culture. These meals are also opportunities for storytelling, laughter, and the passing down of traditions, making them vital to the social fabric of Hobbiton.
Moreover, the structure of Hobbit meals reflects their connection to nature and the seasons. Each meal corresponds to a specific time of day, aligning with the natural rhythms of the Shire. Afternoon tea, for example, is a moment to rest and reflect as the day begins to wind down, while supper marks the end of the day's labor. This harmony with nature underscores the Hobbits' role as stewards of the land, emphasizing their respect for the cycles of life and the importance of balance.
In exploring Hobbit meal traditions, it becomes clear that their love for multiple daily meals is a reflection of their values: simplicity, community, and gratitude. The phrase "What about second breakfast?" is not just a joke but a window into a culture that prioritizes joy, connection, and the appreciation of life's small moments. Through their meals, Hobbits teach us the importance of slowing down, savoring the present, and finding happiness in the abundance that surrounds us. In Hobbiton, every meal is a celebration, and every celebration is an opportunity to strengthen the bonds that define their way of life.
Fuel Your Morning: High-Protein Breakfast Ideas for Energy and Focus
You may want to see also
Explore related products

Second Breakfast Foods: Popular dishes Hobbits enjoy during their mid-morning feast
In the world of Middle-earth, Hobbits are renowned for their love of food and their unique eating habits, which include the delightful tradition of 'Second Breakfast.' This mid-morning meal is a cherished part of Hobbit culture, and their cuisine reflects a preference for hearty, comforting dishes. Here are some popular foods that Hobbits might indulge in during this special feast.
Breads and Pastries: Hobbits are known for their exceptional baking skills, and second breakfast often features an array of freshly baked goods. Warm, crusty bread is a staple, served with sweet butter and an assortment of jams made from the fruits of the Shire. One might find fluffy scones, perhaps with a hint of cinnamon, accompanied by clotted cream and strawberry preserves. The more indulgent Hobbits may enjoy rich, flaky pastries filled with apples or berries, dusted with powdered sugar.
Eggs and Meats: A savory option for second breakfast could include various egg dishes. Scrambled eggs, light and fluffy, seasoned with herbs from the garden, are a favorite. Some Hobbits might prefer a heartier option like a fried egg atop a bed of crispy bacon or sausage. For those with a taste for the finer things, a delicate omelet filled with mushrooms and cheese, sourced from local farms, would be a delightful choice.
Porridges and Stews: On cooler mornings, a warm bowl of porridge is a comforting option. Made with creamy oats and topped with chopped nuts, honey, or dried fruits, it provides a satisfying start to the day. Heartier stews, slow-cooked with tender meats and root vegetables, are also popular. These dishes are often shared communally, with large pots kept warm over the hearth, allowing Hobbits to help themselves throughout the morning.
Cheeses and Fruits: A more casual second breakfast might consist of a platter of fine cheeses, carefully selected from the cellars of the Shire. These could include aged cheddar, creamy brie, and local blue cheeses, served with crackers or slices of fresh apple and pear. Hobbits also enjoy the simplicity of a ripe, juicy peach or a bunch of sweet grapes, making for a refreshing and healthy addition to their mid-morning feast.
The Hobbit's second breakfast is a celebration of good food and community, where these dishes bring friends and family together, fostering a sense of warmth and contentment that is so integral to Hobbit life. It is a time to indulge, share stories, and appreciate the simple pleasures of Middle-earth's culinary delights.
Best Places to Buy Restaurant-Style Breakfast Potatoes for Home Cooking
You may want to see also
Explore related products

Social Aspects: How second breakfast fosters community and bonding among Hobbits
The phrase "but what about second breakfast?" is famously attributed to the character Merry Brandybuck in *The Lord of the Rings*, highlighting the Hobbits' deep-rooted love for meals and their unique daily rhythm. Second breakfast, as a social institution among Hobbits, is more than just a meal—it is a cornerstone of their communal life. This mid-morning repast serves as a daily gathering point where Hobbits come together to share food, stories, and laughter. By fostering regular interaction, second breakfast strengthens the bonds of community, ensuring that neighbors and friends remain connected in a meaningful way. It is a time-honored tradition that reinforces the importance of togetherness in Hobbit culture.
The act of sharing second breakfast encourages a sense of equality and camaraderie among Hobbits. Regardless of social status or occupation, all are welcome to partake in this meal, creating a level playing field for interaction. The preparation and consumption of food are often collaborative efforts, with Hobbits contributing dishes or assisting in the kitchen. This shared labor not only lightens the workload but also deepens the sense of mutual reliance and appreciation. Through these collective activities, second breakfast becomes a symbol of unity, reminding Hobbits of their shared identity and values.
Second breakfast also plays a vital role in the transmission of cultural traditions and stories. As Hobbits gather to eat, they often recount tales of their ancestors, share local news, or discuss the rhythms of the Shire. This oral tradition ensures that history and wisdom are passed down through generations, preserving the cultural heritage of Hobbiton and beyond. The meal provides a relaxed and informal setting for such exchanges, making it easier for younger Hobbits to engage with elders and learn from their experiences. In this way, second breakfast becomes a living link between the past, present, and future of Hobbit society.
Moreover, second breakfast serves as a social safety net, ensuring that no Hobbit goes hungry or feels isolated. The communal nature of the meal means that those who may be less fortunate or living alone are always included in the feast. This practice reflects the Hobbits' inherent kindness and their belief in the importance of looking after one another. By prioritizing shared meals, Hobbit society fosters an environment of care and support, where individuals are valued and their well-being is collectively upheld.
Finally, second breakfast contributes to the overall rhythm and structure of Hobbit life, providing a sense of predictability and stability. In a world that often moves slowly and deliberately, this daily ritual anchors Hobbits in their routines and reinforces their connection to the land and to each other. The anticipation of second breakfast adds joy to the morning hours, while the meal itself offers a moment of pause and reflection before the day’s activities resume. Through this simple yet profound tradition, Hobbits cultivate a way of life that prioritizes community, shared experiences, and the nurturing of relationships.
English Breakfast vs. Darjeeling: Unraveling the Tea Differences
You may want to see also
Explore related products

Historical Origins: Tracing the roots of second breakfast in Middle-earth lore
The concept of "second breakfast" has become an iconic aspect of Hobbit culture in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth lore, immortalized by the beloved character of Bilbo Baggins and later emphasized by his nephew Frodo. To trace its historical origins, we must delve into the unique lifestyle and traditions of the Hobbits, a race known for their love of comfort, food, and regularity. The idea of multiple meals throughout the day is deeply rooted in their agrarian society, where physical labor and a close connection to the land dictated their daily routines. Hobbits, being hearty and industrious folk, required substantial nourishment to sustain their activities, from gardening and farming to the occasional adventure.
Tolkien's detailed world-building in *The Hobbit* and *The Lord of the Rings* reveals that Hobbits typically observed seven meals a day: breakfast, second breakfast, elevenses, luncheon, afternoon tea, dinner, and supper. Among these, second breakfast stands out as a testament to their pragmatic approach to life. Historically, this meal likely originated from the Hobbits' need to refuel after the initial morning activities, such as tending to crops or managing their homesteads. The Shire, their idyllic homeland, was a place of abundance, and their culinary traditions reflected this prosperity. Second breakfast, therefore, was not merely an indulgence but a practical response to their energetic lifestyle.
The phrase "What about second breakfast?" gained prominence through its association with Merry Brandybuck in Peter Jackson's *The Lord of the Rings* film adaptation, though its roots lie firmly in Tolkien's writings. In *The Fellowship of the Ring*, the Hobbits' mealtime habits are explicitly mentioned, providing a canonical basis for this tradition. Tolkien's own experiences during World War I, where regular meals were a luxury, may have influenced his portrayal of the Hobbits' appreciation for food. Their emphasis on second breakfast, thus, can be seen as a reflection of their desire for stability and normalcy in a world often fraught with uncertainty.
From a cultural perspective, second breakfast also underscores the Hobbits' communal nature. Meals were social events, fostering bonds within their tightly-knit communities. This tradition likely evolved as a way to strengthen familial and neighborly ties, with shared meals serving as a cornerstone of their society. The historical origins of second breakfast, therefore, are intertwined with the Hobbits' values of hospitality, camaraderie, and their deep-seated love for the simple joys of life.
In conclusion, the practice of second breakfast in Middle-earth lore is a rich tapestry woven from the Hobbits' agrarian lifestyle, cultural values, and pragmatic needs. Its historical origins highlight their connection to the land, their communal spirit, and their unwavering appreciation for life's comforts. As a cultural artifact, second breakfast not only defines the Hobbits but also serves as a reminder of the enduring appeal of Tolkien's meticulously crafted world.
San Diego's Ultimate Breakfast Burrito: Top Spot Revealed
You may want to see also
Explore related products

Modern Adaptations: How fans incorporate second breakfast into their daily routines today
The phrase "but what about second breakfast?" has become a beloved reference among fans of *The Hobbit* and *The Lord of the Rings*, where Hobbits famously enjoy multiple meals throughout the day. In modern times, fans have embraced this concept, adapting it to fit their daily routines in creative and practical ways. Second breakfast is no longer just a whimsical idea; it’s a functional addition to busy lifestyles, blending fandom with real-world nutrition and productivity. From meal prepping to on-the-go options, fans are finding ways to incorporate this Hobbit-inspired tradition into their modern lives.
One popular modern adaptation is the integration of second breakfast into morning routines as a mid-morning boost. Many fans treat it as a planned snack between breakfast and lunch, often consisting of portable, energy-packed foods like granola bars, fruit, or yogurt. This approach aligns with the Hobbit philosophy of frequent, nourishing meals while catering to the demands of work or school schedules. For those who wake up early, second breakfast serves as a way to refuel and maintain focus until lunchtime, turning a fictional tradition into a practical habit.
Another way fans incorporate second breakfast is by making it a social or family activity. Weekends, in particular, provide the perfect opportunity to slow down and enjoy a more elaborate second breakfast, such as pancakes, muffins, or a charcuterie board. Families and friend groups often use this time to bond over shared love for Middle-earth, sometimes even theming their meals with Hobbit-inspired recipes like seed cake or Lembas bread. This adaptation transforms second breakfast into a cultural and communal experience, blending fandom with everyday life.
For health-conscious fans, second breakfast has become a way to support fitness and wellness goals. Many incorporate protein-rich options like smoothies, hard-boiled eggs, or nuts to sustain energy during workouts or busy days. This adaptation aligns with the Hobbit emphasis on hearty, sustaining meals while catering to modern dietary preferences. Some even use second breakfast as a way to practice mindful eating, taking a moment to pause and enjoy a nourishing snack in the midst of a hectic day.
Finally, the rise of remote work has allowed fans to embrace second breakfast with even more creativity. Home-based professionals often use this meal as a natural break in their workday, stepping away from screens to prepare and enjoy something satisfying. Recipes like overnight oats, avocado toast, or homemade muffins have become staples, offering a balance of convenience and indulgence. This adaptation not only honors the Hobbit tradition but also promotes work-life balance in a modern context.
Incorporating second breakfast into daily routines is more than just a nod to Middle-earth; it’s a way for fans to bring joy, mindfulness, and nourishment into their lives. Whether through quick snacks, social gatherings, or health-focused choices, this modern adaptation proves that even the smallest meals can have a big impact. As fans continue to innovate, second breakfast remains a timeless tradition, bridging the gap between fantasy and reality.
Jack's All-Day Breakfast: What's on the Menu?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
The character Hobbits, particularly Pippin (Peregrin Took), in J.R.R. Tolkien's *The Lord of the Rings* are known for their love of meals, including second breakfast.
It refers to the Hobbits' tradition of having multiple meals throughout the day, with "second breakfast" being one of their scheduled eating times, highlighting their fondness for food.
Yes, the phrase has become a popular meme and quote among fans of *The Lord of the Rings*, often used humorously to express hunger or a love for frequent meals.




































